The Picture-Perfect Crime Scene: The Murder of Rodger Colley and the Wife Who Pointed the Finger

Media Network

07 December 2025

The view of the Colley family home on South Bellagio Drive in St Augustine in late August 2015 was the picture of suburban contentment … until it wasn’t.  Only minutes after an officer from the St Johns County Sheriffs office left the quiet cul de sac on a routine call emergency calls would bring deputies, search teams and crime scene units back out to the neighborhood. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/true-crime--6473403/support.